Inscryption review

Sometimes board game night feels like a trap. Everyone else wants to play the latest Kickstarter-funded smash that comes with 100 miniatures and takes an hour to set up, or maybe some European worker-placement game about farms or power plants or colonialism. You may as well just go along with it, because that's how social pressure works. Inscryption turns that situation into grist for horror, trapping you in a spooky cabin where you're forced to play a deckbuilder. 

Its villain is a shadowy figure, all staring eyes and long fingers, who patiently waits at the table for the game to start. Though you have to play, under pain of death, you can also get up and stretch your legs. There are shelves of trinkets on the walls, a skull, a safe, a cuckoo clock. They're puzzles to solve as part of the larger puzzle: How do you get out of this cabin?

At Inscryption's best, the card game and environment work in harmony. The solution to a puzzle in the cabin is hidden in the smudgy grimoire that explains the card game's rules, and the reward for solving it is a card for your deck. The two progress in parallel. When I was blocked in one because I needed to bash my head against the other for a while, though, that wasn't so fun. 

 Cabin in the woods 

The game within the game may be a deckbuilder, but it's less Slay the Spire and more like the singleplayer mode of a collectible card game—Hearthstone's solo adventures reskinned with a wilderness Americana theme, all rattlesnakes and yeehaw. You collect a deck of animal friends, bullfrogs and wolf cubs and stoats with familiar stats and thematic abilities. The skunk smells so bad enemy cards attacking it have their power reduced; the beaver builds defensive dams.

The mechanics of this card game are wilfully off-kilter and grotesque. Most cards have a blood cost, which has to be paid by sacrificing other cards. (You've got a separate deck of squirrels, free cards worth one blood each, for this purpose.) Rather than being measured in hit points, damage against you and your opponent is counted in teeth, which fall into a pair of scales. You need to get ahead by five teeth to win a round. There's an item sitting on the table that promises to help you tip the scales. It's a pair of pliers.

Your opponent isn't simulating another player and doesn't play by the same rules. He's more like a Dungeon Master or the Dealer from Hand of Fate, narrating encounters and putting on voices and masks to portray NPCs as you cross a map. "Thar's gold in them cards!" he hollers as the prospector, a boss enemy whose pickaxe transforms cards into rocks. Then he takes off the mask and sets up some minis around a campfire to play out a scene with suspicious, starving travelers who offer to warm one of your beasts by their fire. He may be a murderous kidnapper, but he puts in so much effort I kind of respect him.

I spent hours in The Elder Scrolls: Legends playing through the singleplayer storylines, which are fun for their twists: A stone wall across the middle of the table; a storm-tossed pirate ship that slides cards back and forth. Inscryption's twists can be just as novel. For one match, every wolf card gains the ability to fly; in another, a hook drags my cards across the board and turns them against me.

You just activated my trap card

Like most deckbuilders, Inscryption is run-based. Losing means starting over, though you get to design one new card to be found in future runs, and they can be obscenely overpowered if you do it right. Plus, any solved puzzles in the cabin remain solved. Initial defeats still felt like progress, but after my first successful run I had to solve another puzzle and then repeat the victory, and that was when it became a drag. The multi-stage boss battles are initially full of surprises—trading animal pelts for OP cards, for example—that become more chore-like each time they're repeated. The lovely creepiness of a game in which cards beg not to be sacrificed and fungal doctors offer to saw them apart and stitch them together was eroded by repetition. 

Inscryption is the work of Daniel Mullins Games, who previously made Pony Island (in which the Devil forces you to play a buggy auto-runner for eternity), and The Hex (in which videogame characters relive flashbacks to different genres they've been in). All three are games about games, more layered than a winning Great British Bake Off cake. When Inscryption revealed another layer—I won't spoil exactly what it is, but it's significant—it felt more like a chore than a revelation. Where Pony Island was lean and pointed, Inscryption is more like The Hex, which was overstuffed with ideas and didn't do all of them justice.

In its initial hours, Inscryption is an eerie delight full of mystery. That feeling fades long before it ends, and now I think I'd prefer if board game night moved on and we played something else, even if it is some Kickstarter nonsense that comes with five kilograms of plastic figurines and takes half the night to explain.