Январь 2010 Февраль 2010 Март 2010 Апрель 2010 Май 2010
Июнь 2010
Июль 2010 Август 2010
Сентябрь 2010
Октябрь 2010
Ноябрь 2010
Декабрь 2010
Январь 2011
Февраль 2011 Март 2011 Апрель 2011 Май 2011 Июнь 2011 Июль 2011 Август 2011
Сентябрь 2011
Октябрь 2011 Ноябрь 2011 Декабрь 2011 Январь 2012 Февраль 2012 Март 2012 Апрель 2012 Май 2012 Июнь 2012 Июль 2012 Август 2012 Сентябрь 2012 Октябрь 2012 Ноябрь 2012 Декабрь 2012 Январь 2013 Февраль 2013 Март 2013 Апрель 2013 Май 2013 Июнь 2013 Июль 2013 Август 2013 Сентябрь 2013 Октябрь 2013 Ноябрь 2013 Декабрь 2013 Январь 2014 Февраль 2014
Март 2014
Апрель 2014 Май 2014 Июнь 2014 Июль 2014 Август 2014 Сентябрь 2014 Октябрь 2014 Ноябрь 2014 Декабрь 2014 Январь 2015 Февраль 2015 Март 2015 Апрель 2015 Май 2015 Июнь 2015 Июль 2015 Август 2015 Сентябрь 2015 Октябрь 2015 Ноябрь 2015 Декабрь 2015 Январь 2016 Февраль 2016 Март 2016 Апрель 2016 Май 2016 Июнь 2016 Июль 2016 Август 2016 Сентябрь 2016 Октябрь 2016 Ноябрь 2016 Декабрь 2016 Январь 2017 Февраль 2017 Март 2017 Апрель 2017 Май 2017
Июнь 2017
Июль 2017
Август 2017 Сентябрь 2017 Октябрь 2017 Ноябрь 2017 Декабрь 2017 Январь 2018 Февраль 2018 Март 2018 Апрель 2018 Май 2018 Июнь 2018 Июль 2018 Август 2018 Сентябрь 2018 Октябрь 2018 Ноябрь 2018 Декабрь 2018 Январь 2019
Февраль 2019
Март 2019 Апрель 2019 Май 2019 Июнь 2019 Июль 2019 Август 2019 Сентябрь 2019 Октябрь 2019 Ноябрь 2019 Декабрь 2019 Январь 2020
Февраль 2020
Март 2020 Апрель 2020 Май 2020 Июнь 2020 Июль 2020 Август 2020 Сентябрь 2020 Октябрь 2020 Ноябрь 2020 Декабрь 2020 Январь 2021 Февраль 2021 Март 2021 Апрель 2021 Май 2021 Июнь 2021 Июль 2021 Август 2021 Сентябрь 2021 Октябрь 2021 Ноябрь 2021 Декабрь 2021 Январь 2022 Февраль 2022 Март 2022 Апрель 2022 Май 2022 Июнь 2022 Июль 2022 Август 2022 Сентябрь 2022 Октябрь 2022 Ноябрь 2022 Декабрь 2022 Январь 2023 Февраль 2023 Март 2023 Апрель 2023 Май 2023 Июнь 2023 Июль 2023 Август 2023 Сентябрь 2023 Октябрь 2023 Ноябрь 2023 Декабрь 2023 Январь 2024 Февраль 2024 Март 2024 Апрель 2024 Май 2024 Июнь 2024 Июль 2024 Август 2024 Сентябрь 2024 Октябрь 2024 Ноябрь 2024
1 2 3 4 5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Game News |

If history can tell us anything about the Palworld patent lawsuit, it's that Nintendo's out for blood

Earlier this week, Palworld developer Pocketpair found itself in the crosshairs of a Nintendo patent lawsuit, making it the latest target in an infamous history of Nintendo legal action. Nintendo hasn't yet clarified the specifics of its lawsuit claims, but analysts and legal experts have already been offering their takes on how strong its case might be.

Serkan Toto, CEO of Japanese game industry consultant Kantan Games, told GamesRadar that "Nintendo is going into this lawsuit thinking that they're going to win. And I fear, looking at the track record, it's highly likely that they win." Having explored Nintendo's litigation history, I don't know if I'm qualified to speak to its odds—but I'm pretty confident it won't be pulling any punches.

Writing in the US, it's difficult to track the specifics of Nintendo's legal disputes in Japan. Some stories punch through the language barrier, like its 2018 lawsuit against mobile game developer Colopl over patent infringements involving virtual joysticks and sleep mode confirmation screens, which ended in a settlement awarding Nintendo ¥3.3 billion—somewhere in the realm of $23 million today.

Otherwise, Japanese patent suit records aren't readily available overseas, and Nintendo's Japanese corporate website, where it announced that it was pursuing legal action against Pocketpair, only translates some press releases into English. From Nintendo's history with American litigation, however, we can see a clear image of a corporation that's meticulously, overwhelmingly devoted to the protection of its intellectual property.

The best word for Nintendo's legal strategy might be "vengeful," and even that could be putting it lightly. As early as the '80s, Nintendo had no qualms about filing lawsuits as a means of retaliation. In 1989, unable to achieve a ban on videogame rentals, Nintendo found another way to draw blood from rental chains: In Nintendo of America, Inc. v. Blockbuster Entertainment Corp., Nintendo sued Blockbuster for photocopying its copyrighted game manuals to include with its rentals, eventually settling out of court for an undisclosed amount and forcing Blockbuster to distribute unofficial alternatives.

More recently, Nintendo has waged a long-running war against perceived copyright infractions online. YouTubers have endured years of widespread copyright strike campaigns over Nintendo game footage and music. ROM sites, hacked console distributors, and emulator developers, who've received their own share of Nintendo DMCA takedowns, have more recently been brought into court by escalating Nintendo lawsuits as it attempts to stamp out piracy wherever it can reach. And Nintendo's lawsuits have had a very reliable success record.

Some, like Sergio Moreno, a former seller of modded Switch hardware who was also ordered to destroy his hacked devices, received court injunctions preventing further copyright or patent infringement. Others, like ROM site operators Jacob and Cristian Mathias, faced fines that—in the Mathias's case—exceeded $12 million.

Nintendo's most brutal copyright case was suffered by Gary Bowser, a Canadian programmer affiliated with Team-Xecuter, a team of hackers who've been tied to a series of lawsuits that have awarded Nintendo millions in damages. After pleading guilty to charges of "conspiracy to circumvent technological measures and to traffic in circumvention devices," Bowser—a 54-year-old man with elephantitis-related chronic pain—has been fined a total of $14.5 million. "The sentence was like a message to other people," Bowser said after leaving prison in 2024.

Before Pocketpair earned its ire, Nintendo's last legal bloodbath began in 2023, when it lashed out at the Switch emulation ecosystem as a kind of divine retribution for the sin of leaking Tears of the Kingdom. Once TotK started appearing on pirate sites ahead of its official release, Nintendo targeted DMCA takedowns at Github software repos that Switch emulators relied on to decrypt and run game software, pirated or otherwise.

Months later, Nintendo had set its sights on the emulators themselves. In late February 2024, Nintendo filed a lawsuit against Tropic Haze LLC, developers of the Switch emulator Yuzu, claiming that the emulator's circumvention of proprietary Nintendo encryption software was a violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (that's what the "DMCA" you always hear about is short for), which forbids technology "primarily designed to circumvent technological measures that effectively control access to copyrighted works."

Within a week, the lawsuit concluded in a settlement awarding Nintendo $2.4 million and shuttering Yuzu's development and distribution, alongside "any other website or system that Defendant or its members own or control, directly or indirectly, that involves Nintendo’s Intellectual Property, to Plaintiff’s control." That included Citra, the 3DS emulator also developed by Tropic Haze, which shut down shortly after. With such a fast turnaround, it felt like Nintendo had spent the better part of a year ensuring that when it pulled the trigger on the Yuzu lawsuit, the shot wouldn't miss.

While Nintendo's lawsuit success record tends to have an obliterating effect on whoever's on the receiving end, it's worth noting that some have managed to survive a brush with its legal onslaught—emulators included. While Nintendo was able to prevent Dolphin's Steam release in 2023 by writing a letter to Valve, the GameCube and Wii emulator is still freely available. Nintendo claimed Dolphin also violates the DMCA's anti-circumvention statutes, but notably has never brought legal action against the emulator itself.

While the DMCA forbids technology "primarily designed" for piracy, circumventing copyright protection measures is permitted under US copyright law if it's "for the purpose of enabling interoperability of an independently created computer program." In Nintendo's original lawsuit filing against Yuzu, it made repeated reference to sections of Yuzu's now-offline website and Patreon page that could be construed as endorsing or encouraging piracy, potentially damaging what hopes Tropic Haze might've had to claim Yuzu wasn't "primarily designed" to circumvent copyright protections. The much simpler encryption of the Wii (and complete lack of encryption on the GameCube) likely insulate Dolphin from the same line of attack—especially if its backed by a healthy awareness of how its developers' messaging can be used against them.

The protections ensuring Dolphin's survival were, in part, brought about by one of Nintendo's earliest defeats in 1992's Lewis Galoob Toys, Inc. v. Nintendo of America, Inc., where Nintendo attempted to sue Galoob over its Game Genie, which had been reverse-engineered from NES hardware and, Nintendo claimed, infringed on its copyright. The courts ultimately found in Galoob's favor which, alongside rulings like Sega v. Accolade in the same year, helped cement reverse engineering as being beyond the scope of copyright infringement in American law.

Nintendo isn't omnipotent. Despite how it can sometimes seem, it can't win a lawsuit simply by declaring one. But, if its record is any indication, it'll have spent the eight months since Palworld's release crafting the loudest message a lawsuit can tell.



Читайте также

Not content with finally getting Stardew Valley 1.6 live on all platforms, Eric Barone has piled a bunch of other new stuff on top of it in yet another big update

Ubisoft's NFT dumpster fire flares up as a matchmaking bug leaves every player connecting and losing to the same confused, unkillable guy

Star Wars Outlaws has a new creative director, promises more work on three 'key areas': Combat, stealth, and controls




Game24.pro — паблик игровых новостей в календарном формате на основе технологичной новостной информационно-поисковой системы с элементами искусственного интеллекта, гео-отбора и возможностью мгновенной публикации авторского контента в режиме Free Public. Game24.pro — ваши Game News сегодня и сейчас в Вашем городе.

Опубликовать свою новость, реплику, комментарий, анонс и т.д. можно мгновенно — здесь.


Персональные новости

Николай Цискаридзе на марафоне Знание.Первые: «Если человек развивается, он живет»

Мировая премьера концерта – симфонии «Русскому Донбассу» состоялась в Чите

Александр Малинин и симфонический оркестр Москвы: незабываемый вечер в честь дня рождения артиста

Актерское агентство Киноактер. Актерское агентство в Москве.